Top 10 Players in the Premiership (Categories)

[Clowgon]

Goalkeepers: Van der sar, Petr Cech, David James, Brad Friedel, Shay Given, Jussi Jaaskelainen, Jose Renia, Thomas Kuzack, Paul Robbinson and Scot Carson.

Defenders: Rio Ferdinand, Nejama Vidic, Patrice Evra, Wes Brown, Matthew Upson, John Terry, John O'Shea, Jose Bosingwa, Rafael Da Silva.

Mid: Michael Carrick, Owen Hargreaves, Cristiano Ronaldo, Gerrard, Xabi Alonso, Frank Lampard, Ryan Giggs, Luke Young, Gareth Barry and Michael Essien when hes fit.

Strikers: Wayne Rooney, Fernando Torres, Carlos Tevez, Roque Santa Cruz, Emily Heskey, Micheal Owen, Jo, Robinho, Craig Bellamy and Kenwyne Jones.

I think you all would agree I'm quite right here. :)

[Skajo]

You copied and pasted that list from here (http://www.manutd.com/default.sps?pagegid=%7B91EA3BE2-963A-4BAB-802C-F46A0EF3FCA3%7D&page=1).

[Jibbish]

Luke young is a defender not midfield.
And add abonglahor to the strikers and its perfect

[Jack.Lfc]

Hargreaves? no mascherano? Reina won golden gloves last 2 years? John o'shea? Rafael de silva? No nicolas anelka or adebayor or van persie?
Bosingwa is overated


JO JO JO JO haha

[Geraint]

Ashley Young?

[Rarelime]

Berbatov? Drogba?

[busybabes]

luke young :lol:

Clueless

[Brody]

Scot Carsonn:S hes shocking this year

Strange when u put luke young in top midfielders and not fabregas:S

[Wootzeh]

Scott Carson?

What exactly is the point of this thread?

[Malachy]

Goalkeepers: Van der sar, Petr Cech, David James, Brad Friedel, Shay Given, Jussi Jaaskelainen, Jose Renia, Thomas Kuzack, Paul Robbinson and Scot Carson.




Defenders: Rio Ferdinand, Nejama Vidic, Patrice Evra, Wes Brown, Matthew Upson, John Terry, John O'Shea, Jose Bosingwa, Rafael Da Silva.


Mid: Michael Carrick, Owen Hargreaves, Cristiano Ronaldo, Gerrard, Xabi Alonso, Frank Lampard, Ryan Giggs, Luke Young, Gareth Barry and Michael Essien when hes fit.


Strikers: Wayne Rooney, Fernando Torres, Carlos Tevez, Roque Santa Cruz, Emily Heskey, Micheal Owen, Jo, Robinho, Craig Bellamy and Kenwyne Jones.


I think you all would agree I'm quite right here. :)

I don't think anyone agrees that your right here.
Also,
Thomas Kuszcak?
Luke Young?
Scott Carson?
Is this some kind of sick joke?

[Brody]

strange when u include jo over Rvp too

and when you call Emile Heskey
Emily oh deary me

[Geraint]

No Zaki? No Gomes?

[RareIce]

made some changes








Goalkeepers: Van der sar, Petr Cech, David James, Brad Friedel, Shay Given, Jussi Jaaskelainen, Jose Renia, Almunia, Paul Robbinson and Joe hart

Defenders: Rio Ferdinand, Nejama Vidic, Patrice Evra, kolo toure, Matthew Upson, John Terry, martin laursen, Jose Bosingwa, Gallas, jakielka

Mid: Fabregas, Steven ireland, Cristiano Ronaldo, Gerrard, Xabi Alonso, Frank Lampard, Ashley young, SWP, Mascherano and Michael Essien

Strikers: Wayne Rooney, Fernando Torres, Carlos Tevez, Berbatov, Drogba, Adebayor, Van persie, Robinho, Craig Bellamy and Walcott.

[Wootzeh]

WHERES STUART DOWNING?

;)

[Minstrels]

I wont bother commenting, all I'll say is that is all wrong.

[Jack.Lfc]

Ok heres mine, not in order tho just who i think would be in the top 10.

Goalkeepers - Cech, Reina, Van der sar, Almunia, given, Gomes, james, Howard,friedel, jaskellinin

Defence - Evra, Vidic, Ferdinand, Skrtel, Lescott, Gallas, Terry, Carvalho, Laursen,

Midfield - Gerrard, Mascherano, Fabregas, Ronaldo, Young, Lampard, Barry, Ireland

Strikers - Torres, Rooney, Van Persie, Anelka, Robinho, Defoe,

Someone finish it im tired ;)

[luce]

Where are the Aston Villa boys! Reina? I don't think you're quite right there! Far to many united players you have the best part of our squad!!

[Jack.Lfc]

Reina is one of the best in the world, even all the Everton fans agree with me on that one.

[Clowgon]

You copied and pasted that list from here (http://www.manutd.com/default.sps?pagegid=%7B91EA3BE2-963A-4BAB-802C-F46A0EF3FCA3%7D&page=1).

No.


Luke young is a defender not midfield.
And add abonglahor to the strikers and its perfect

Ashley Young i meant. :$


Hargreaves? no mascherano? Reina won golden gloves last 2 years? John o'shea? Rafael de silva? No nicolas anelka or adebayor or van persie?

Bosingwa is overated.

Yeah slightly but he is a quality defender. Mascherano hasn't really proved himself at Liverpool quite yet. I have not once seen him put in a top performance or if he has he hasn't done it consistently which a World Class player should be doing often.




[quote=Geraint;5596756]Ashley Young?

That's right.


Berbatov? Drogba?

Berbatov has scored a few crucial goals for us this season but he is no where near his best when he played for spurs 2 seasons ago. Drogba has gone completly done, you can see it when his playing that he clearly can't be bothered.


luke young :lol:

Clueless

You can talk mate, go look at your other thread and we'll see who is clueless. ;)


Scot Carsonn:S hes shocking this year

Strange when u put luke young in top midfielders and not fabregas:S

Scot Carson - I ran out of Goalkeepers. :$

As i said Luke Young = Ashley Young, too be honest fabregas has been in and out this season through injury so i can't really put in him.


I don't think anyone agrees that your right here.
Also,
Thomas Kuszcak?
Luke Young?
Scott Carson?
Is this some kind of sick joke?


No, not really.


strange when u include jo over Rvp too

and when you call Emile Heskey
Emily oh deary me

Who is Rvp? Yeah my Grammar is prettie poor. I'm working on it. :8


No Zaki? No Gomes?

Zaki has scored some good goals against top opposition but hes not that good, Gomes: never seen him play the way he played at PSV. Far too clumsy in goal this term.


made some changes


Goalkeepers: Van der sar, Petr Cech, David James, Brad Friedel, Shay Given, Jussi Jaaskelainen, Jose Renia, Almunia, Paul Robbinson and Joe hart


Defenders: Rio Ferdinand, Nejama Vidic, Patrice Evra, kolo toure, Matthew Upson, John Terry, martin laursen, Jose Bosingwa, Gallas, jakielka

Mid: Fabregas, Steven ireland, Cristiano Ronaldo, Gerrard, Xabi Alonso, Frank Lampard, Ashley young, SWP, Mascherano and Michael Essien

Strikers: Wayne Rooney, Fernando Torres, Carlos Tevez, Berbatov, Drogba, Adebayor, Van persie, Robinho, Craig Bellamy and Walcott.



Lol. Is this some sort of wind up?....... YOU'VE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME! :O


WHERES STUART DOWNING?

;)

PFFT. :eusa_snoo


I wont bother commenting, all I'll say is that is all wrong.

You can just get out of my thread.


Where are the Aston Villa boys! Reina? I don't think you're quite right there! Far to many united players you have the best part of our squad!!


Reina has deffo got to be in the Top 10. I can't see anyone replacing him. Aston Villa, your rite there i should of added at least GA.

My bad. Oh well. :$

[Tristan]

lolllllll.
damn you're stupid.
it's even still surprising me now.

[Brody]

oh dear mate. u make no sense?
Fabregas has been in and out so u cant put him in? Essien has been out since like October with a cruciate ligament injury. So how comes hes in there?

Rvp= Robin Van Persie

Scot Carson. even almunia is better than him this year and almunia is pretty poor .

[RareIce]

youve just proved to everyone you know nothing about football, you put!
JO and emile heskey plus kenwyne jones before berbatov LMAO funny! Really funny and im a city fan and i think berbatov is playing his best football now.

[Jack.Lfc]

Urg, mascherano was Liverpools best player last season, hasnt been quite his best this season but starting to get back to his normal self now.

[Minstrels]

No Stephen Ireland...

[Clowgon]

lolllllll.
damn you're stupid.
it's even still surprising me now.

Don't call me stupid. Have some respect. If you can't speak to fellow members with a slightly un noobish, cocky attitude then i suggest you come off this forum for good.


oh dear mate. u make no sense?
Fabregas has been in and out so u cant put him in? Essien has been out since like October with a cruciate ligament injury. So how comes hes in there?

Rvp= Robin Van Persie

Scot Carson. even almunia is better than him this year and almunia is pretty poor .


I don't think i can argue with you there. :$


youve just proved to everyone you know nothing about football, you put!
JO and emile heskey plus kenwyne jones before berbatov LMAO funny! Really funny and im a city fan and i think berbatov is playing his best football now.

Emile Heskey has been quite good for Wigan this term You haven't watched him play for Wigan this season have you? Kenwyne Jones has been a great asset to Sunderland this season he has scored some good goals and his movement on and off the ball has been spot on.

As i said Berbatov has scored some goals for us but he hasn't quite performed the same has he did for spurs 2 years ago. He needs to move and work a lot more harder.

I admit it I'm not no footie expect but i know my stuff.
No-one on here can say they know everything about football. Not you not minstrels...... Sorry. :(

[Jordie]

its his opinion. Although i dont agree with some of them you dont have to keep saying he knows nothing about the game.

[RareIce]

Don't call me stupid. Have some respect. If you can't speak to fellow members with a slightly un noobish, cocky attitude then i suggest you come off this forum for good.




I don't think i can argue with you there. :$



Emile Heskey has been quite good for Wigan this term You haven't watched him play for Wigan this season have you? Kenwyne Jones has been a great asset to Sunderland this season he has scored some good goals and his movement on and off the ball has been spot on.

As i said Berbatov has scored some goals for us but he hasn't quite performed the same has he did for spurs 2 years ago. He needs to move and work a lot more harder.

I admit it I'm not no footie expect but i know my stuff.
No-one on here can say they know everything about football. Not you not minstrels...... Sorry. :(


no i dont no everything about football but i know that 30 million pound berbatov is better than 3.5m emile heskey i accept its your opinion but i have to disagree.

[Minstrels]

its his opinion. Although i dont agree with some of them you dont have to keep saying he knows nothing about the game.
Alas! Someone has seen why I haven't bothered having a go at the selection of players on show here.

[MeRkAgE]

Clowgon you make me laugh, listing all the united players.
YOU ARE NOT A FAN, and you are gay.

[Minstrels]

Clowgon you make me laugh, listing all the united players.
YOU ARE NOT A FAN, and you are gay.
Why did I pass the ball Greg? We would of won 3:2. :'(

[Clowgon]

Alas! Someone has seen why I haven't bothered having a go at the selection of players on show here.

Post your line-up please.


Clowgon you make me laugh, listing all the united players.
YOU ARE NOT A FAN, and you are gay.

I'm pleased that i can keep your small little brain of yours entertained, enjoy the rest of the show! ;)

GAY AND PROUND MATE. ;)

[Minstrels]

I'll do it tomorrow, going bed now.

[Zak]

Van der sar for top goalkeeper#

I remember buying a football shirt with Van der sar on when I was a child on Holiday in Cyprus. Back then he was playing for Juventus!

[Pyroka]

Lol oh dear, Clowgon just failed on an epic proportion.

I don't want to post my own line-up, I just wanted to laugh at you and your 'remarks', if thats what they could be called.

[brandon]

You're well off the money with that one I'm afraid

[Clowgon]

Lol oh dear, Clowgon just failed on an epic proportion.

I don't want to post my own line-up, I just wanted to laugh at you and your 'remarks', if thats what they could be called.

Glad I've kept you entertained. :D


You're well off the money with that one I'm afraid

Line up please. :@

[leah]

You copied and pasted that list from here (http://www.manutd.com/default.sps?pagegid=%7B91EA3BE2-963A-4BAB-802C-F46A0EF3FCA3%7D&page=1).
owned lol

[Tristan]

Don't call me stupid. Have some respect. If you can't speak to fellow members with a slightly un noobish, cocky attitude then i suggest you come off this forum for good.

LOL.
Just do yourself a favour and shut up.

"un noobish"? Lol. :rolleyes:

And it's not "fellow members" - it's just you.

[Browney]

Gk: Cech, Jaaskelinen(sp?), Given
Def: Vidic, Terry, Upson
Mid: A Young, Carrick, Gerrard
Fwd: Rooney, Torres, Cisse (;))

[JackBuddy]

Every Man City player, obviously.

[Ohirian]

Well, heres my list on the top ten this year.

Goalkeepers: Edwin Van der Sar, Jose Reina, Manuel Almunia, Brad Friedel, Mark Schwarzer, Shay Given, David James, Robert Green, Jussi Jaaskelainen and Tim Howard.

Defenders: Jose Bosingwa, Nemanja Vidic, Phil Jagielka, William Gallas, Joleen Lescott, Matthew Upson, Gael Clichy, Martin Laursen, Maynor Figueroa and Jamie Carragher.

Midfield: Christiano Ronaldo, Frank Lampard, Steven Gerrard, Xavi Alonso, Gareth Barry, Ashley Young, Mikel Arteta, Shaun Wright-Phillips, Steven Ireland and Antonio Valencia.

Strikers: Gabriel Agbonlahor, Robin van Persie, Nicolas Anelka, Carlton Cole, De Souza Robinho, Amir Zaki, Emmanuel Adebayor, Djibril Cisse, Peter Crouch and Wayne Rooney.

[Clowgon]

LOL.
Just do yourself a favour and shut up.

"un noobish"? Lol. :rolleyes:

And it's not "fellow members" - it's just you.

I refuse to shut up. 17 and your acting like a little silly baby. What a shame.

[Soka]

Why have you put John O'Shea on the list? Hes a utility player and has only played the last 5? games to cover for Patrice Evra. My personal top 11 from games I've seen this season are; and I'm not just picking the usual top 4 players. I don't think Ronaldo has played as well this season as last, yes he has scored, but done nothing else in a match.

Van Der Sar
G. Johnson, Vidic, Jagielka, Bosingwa
Lampard, Ireland, Gerrard, T. Cahill (since back)
Agbonglahor, C. Cole

[Throne Sofa]

Just for the sake of me being bored:

(In no particular order for all). This isn't just for this season, but how I rate them.

Top 10 GK's: Cech, Reina, Van Der Sar, Almunia, Howard, Given, Hart, James, Gordon, Sorenson.

Top 10 Def's: Vidic, Ferdinand, Terry, Carvalho, Gallas, Carragher, Evra, A.Cole, Sagna, Woodgate.

Top 10 Mids: C.Ronaldo, Carrick, Lampard, Essien, Gerrard, Alonso, Fabregas, Ashley Young, Gareth Barry.

Top 10 Attackers: Robinho, Anelka, Van Persie, Rooney, Tevez, Berbatov, Torres, Drogba, Adebayor, Robbie Keane.

[Throne Sofa]

Why have you put John O'Shea on the list? Hes a utility player and has only played the last 5? games to cover for Patrice Evra. My personal top 11 from games I've seen this season are; and I'm not just picking the usual top 4 players. I don't think Ronaldo has played as well this season as last, yes he has scored, but done nothing else in a match.

Van Der Sar
G. Johnson, Vidic, Jagielka, Bosingwa
Lampard, Ireland, Gerrard, T. Cahill (since back)
Agbonglahor, C. Cole

Surprised to see that despite Bosingwa never playing left back this season, you've included him. Also you've chosen to exclude the Premiership's top goal scorer?

[Soka]

Surprised to see that despite Bosingwa never playing left back this season, you've included him. Also you've chosen to exclude the Premiership's top goal scorer?

You've wrongly assumed i've done it per position from the way I've laid it out. I have just picked my 4 best defenders.. not best rightback, best centre halfs, best left back. So no, Bosingwa has never played left back, nor is he left back in the 11 I have selected, he is one of the four best defenders in my opinion this season. Your asking why I've not included Anelka. Firstly, just because they're top goal scorer it does not automatically mean they're best player. Secondly I believe Anelka has had some good games where hes had the ball put on a plate for him to score from the likes of Lampard so hes scored lots. Anelkas work rate is poor, hes lazy and sulks. He might be top goal scorer but he doesn't deserve a place in my top 11. Agbonlahor and Cole work hard in matches and are both on form with Cole scoring a goal a game, bar the game against United which is understandable.

[Throne Sofa]

Bosingwa best four defenders in the premiership this season? He's been pretty good, but not amazing to justify that sort of a place. In all fairness, I think Ashley's performed much more consistently than him.

I think you need to understand where Anelka played for us under Scolari for the majority of the season. He was in a position where when attacking, he was only encouraged to be inside the box, you can't be running around tirelessly, it's not what is required of him. Performances can't come of this, and isolation is sometimes the result and that sometimes leads to poor performances when the midfield fail to get a ball through to him. He may not be the best player this season upfront, but he's been the best goalscorer and at the end of the day that's what strikers are judged on.

[busybabes]

Evra at LB surely..

[Jack.Lfc]

Evra at LB surely..

Agree with you on that, evra is best lb in prem

[e5]

Why isn't martin laursen in the defenders? :S

[Jack.Lfc]

Why isn't martin laursen in the defenders? :S

He was on my list i fink, cba chekin

[Mortalized]

jo? are you ******* serious

[Skajo]

Green, Van Der Sar, Cech, Reina, Almunia, Friedel, Given, Myhill, Turnball, Gomes

Ferdinand, Vidic, Carragher, Clichy, Evra, Young, Terry, Samba, Turner, Lescott

Carrick, Fabregas, Gerrard, Lampard, Young, Milner, Downing, Barry, Arteta, Modric

Van Persie, Tevez, Torres, Anelka, Defoe, Cahill, Fuller, Robinho, Santa Cruz, Ronaldo

Any questions?