I agree and I think the Habbox God usertitle suffices for dedicated non-staff members. Although I seem to be the only one here not invited to that club!
I came up with the wiki and set it up. It's actually a really bitter sweet thing for me. Over the years I spent hundreds of hours building custom code for the site and the forum. The most successful thing I did ended up being the wiki, which I set up in about one weekend of work. Even when I left in 2011 I thought, I doubt anyone will bother maintaining/updating this, and when I came back and saw that you all had, I was shocked. And happy. But still not sure how I feel about that being the lasting thing I did here. The wiki is great! But there was and is so much more I'd have preferred to have worked out instead. That said, I wonder if Habbox can somehow use the wiki to gain back ground lost to other fansites. It makes Habbox unique and I wonder if there's a way to maximize the benefits from that as much as Habbox can.
You mostly worked with him when he was burnt out.... he wasn't always like that. But I think your criticism is still fair enough.
I can't speak for Mathew but I would say Alex3213 deserves merit, perhaps not HoF though.